The Culinary Scene on Longboat Key: Best Restaurants and Cafes

Longboat Key is known for its stunning beaches, luxury living, and vibrant culinary scene. Whether you're seeking a fine dining experience or a casual cafe, this barrier island offers a variety of options to suit every palate. Here, we explore some of Longboat Key’s best restaurants and cafes, perfect for locals and visitors. If you're considering Longboat Key, FL, real estate, these dining establishments are part of the charm of living on this beautiful island.

One of Longboat Key’s most beloved dining spots, Dry Dock Waterfront Grill offers an exceptional waterfront dining experience. Known for its fresh seafood, this casual yet refined restaurant is a favorite for locals and visitors alike. With its scenic views and boat access, Dry Dock is an ideal spot to enjoy dishes such as grouper sandwiches and lobster tails while enjoying Sarasota Bay's beauty.

Lazy Lobster of Longboat Key is a go-to spot for seafood lovers, with a menu offering a wide range of lobster and seafood dishes. The restaurant prides itself on providing a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere, making it perfect for a family dinner or a casual night out. The lobster bisque and Lazy Lobster Classic are must-try dishes featuring a half-pound of lobster tail.

Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Pub, with its historic building and waterside seating, provides a charming, Old Florida vibe. Situated on Sarasota Bay, this spot is known for its fresh, locally sourced seafood and relaxing environment. Mar Vista’s beachside views and expansive outdoor seating area create the perfect setting for enjoying fresh fish tacos, stone crab, and seasonal specialties.

Shore is a stylish, contemporary restaurant that blends modern design with an island feel. The menu features a variety of seafood options, including fresh catches of the day, as well as delicious steaks and salads. With its sleek, open-air dining space, Shore offers an upscale yet comfortable dining experience that reflects the essence of Longboat Key’s casual luxury lifestyle.

Euphemia Haye is one of Longboat Key’s most renowned fine dining establishments. Set in a charming, converted home, this restaurant offers a romantic, intimate atmosphere and a menu that combines continental and American cuisine. Signature dishes like roasted duckling and filet mignon are popular choices, but the dessert room upstairs is not to be missed, offering a variety of homemade pies and sweets.

Maison Blanche offers an exceptional dining experience for those seeking French-inspired fine cuisine. With its minimalist decor and focus on high-quality ingredients, this restaurant exudes elegance. Maison Blanche is known for its perfectly executed dishes, such as foie gras and rack of lamb, and its extensive wine list. It’s perfect for a special occasion or a memorable evening out on Longboat Key.

Chart House is a waterfront restaurant known for its fresh seafood and prime steaks. Located on Longboat Key’s southern end, this restaurant offers stunning views of the bay and a sophisticated, welcoming ambiance. The menu features signature dishes such as macadamia-crusted mahi and slow-roasted prime rib. Chart House also boasts an extensive wine list and offers a happy hour with specially priced drinks and appetizers.

Blue Dolphin Cafe is a local favorite for a casual breakfast or lunch. This charming cafe offers a classic American menu with a focus on hearty breakfast items like omelets, pancakes, and waffles. With its cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Blue Dolphin Cafe is the perfect spot to start your day on Longboat Key.

Longbeach Cafe is a hidden gem on the north end of Longboat Key. It offers an extensive menu of breakfast and lunch items. Known for its affordable prices and large portions, this cafe provides a laid-back, beachy vibe, making it a popular choice for locals and tourists. Longbeach Cafe is a reliable choice whether you're in the mood for a simple cup of coffee or a full breakfast spread.

Turtle Coffee Bar offers a relaxed, coastal setting for those looking to enjoy a good cup of coffee, tea, or a light snack. Known for its fresh, organic ingredients, this cafe specializes in serving locally roasted coffee and a variety of pastries and smoothies. It’s the perfect spot to unwind with a book or meet friends for a mid-morning break.

Penny’s Ice Cream offers a variety of homemade ice creams and frozen desserts for a sweet treat. This charming, old-fashioned ice cream parlor is a favorite among families and visitors seeking to cool off after a day at the beach. With unique flavors that rotate regularly, Penny’s Ice Cream provides an ever-changing selection of delicious options.

Foxi Coffee is a small but vibrant cafe that serves high-quality espresso drinks, teas, and pastries. This locally owned spot prides itself on creating a welcoming environment for customers to relax or work. With its trendy yet unpretentious vibe, Foxi Coffee is perfect for a quick coffee run or a longer stay to enjoy the relaxed Longboat Key atmosphere.

Via la Casa is a cozy cafe with a European flair. It offers a range of coffee drinks, light lunches, and fresh-baked goods. Its warm, welcoming atmosphere makes it an excellent spot for a leisurely breakfast or a casual lunch. The outdoor seating area is ideal for those who want to enjoy Longboat Key’s pleasant weather while sipping their favorite beverage.

Sips is a locally loved cafe specializing in artisan coffee and various small bites. The cafe's minimalist decor and cozy seating make it a great place to catch up with friends or enjoy a quiet moment alone. Sips is particularly well-known for its unique coffee blends and friendly service, making it a must-visit on Longboat Key for coffee enthusiasts.

Since starting her career in 1978, Judy Kepecz-Hays has built a successful real estate business, serving clients from across the globe. Judy’s expertise is a combination of intuition and extensive experience. Her real estate focuses primarily on waterfront and luxury properties in Sarasota and the surrounding islands, including Longboat Key, Lido Key, Bird Key, downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key, and Casey Key.

With over 40 years of experience and over $3.4 billion in sales, Judy and her team have earned international recognition as specialists in luxury and waterfront properties in Sarasota and the surrounding areas. What sets Judy apart is her dedication to forming strong client relationships and her passion for delivering exceptional results, whether for buyers or sellers.

If you're looking to buy or sell a home or have any questions about the Longboat Key, FL, real estate market, contact Judy Kepecz-Hays today.